A Fair Way to Determine a National Champion
Reorganize the out-of-control conference expansion into 7 BCS conferences based on region of the country. 10 teams each. 9-game conference schedule (everyone plays everyone). 1 out-of-conference BCS game (permanent rival like FSU-Florida or rotate opponents). 1 non-AQ game vs WAC, CUSA, etc. 1 FCS game against an in-state opponent. 12 regular season games.
#1 & #2 in each BCS conference play each other again in the Conference Championship game. 7 Champions enter an 8-team playoff with 1 at-large team. Takes 16 games to win the National Championship. 16 teams get a crack at it. 6 playoff games to be played at Rose, Fiesta, Cotton, Sugar, Orange, & a new bowl in the new Indianapolis Colts domed stadium. Game #7 the National Championship rotates between the bowl sites like it does now.
| Big East | Atlantic Coast | Southeastern | Southwest | |||
| Boston College | Maryland | Florida | Louisiana State | |||
| Syracuse | Virginia | Georgia | Memphis | |||
| Connecticut | Virginia Tech | South Carolina | Arkansas | |||
| Rutgers | North Carolina | Wake Forest | Oklahoma | |||
| Penn State | North Carolina State | Tennessee | Oklahoma State | |||
| Pittsburgh | Duke | Vanderbilt | Texas | |||
| West Virginia | Clemson | Alabama | Texas A&M | |||
| Cincinnati | Georgia Tech | Auburn | Texas Tech | |||
| Kentucky | Florida State | Mississippi | Texas Christian | |||
| Louisville | Miami | Mississippi State | Baylor |
- Finally a real eastern conference w/ Penn St as the anchor
- ACC classic w/ instate rivals Va Tech & Miami added in
- SEC loses the geographic outliers Arkansas, LSU, Kentucky & picks up NC w/ Wake
- Old SWC & Big 12 South
| Big Ten | Great Midwest | Pacific | Ind. | |||
| Ohio State | Kansas | California | Army | |||
| Michigan | Kansas State | Stanford | Navy | |||
| Michigan State | Missouri | UCLA | Air Force | |||
| Notre Dame | Iowa | USC | ||||
| Indiana | Iowa State | Arizona | ||||
| Purdue | Nebraska | Arizona State | ||||
| Illinois | Colorado | Oregon | ||||
| Northwestern | Utah | Oregon State | ||||
| Wisconsin | Brigham Young | Washington | ||||
| Minnesota | Boise State | Washington State |
- B1G classic w/ an Iowa for ND trade
- a new conference is born, the GMC stretches from Illinois to Oregon
- PAC-10 classic
- military schools are Ind by themselves
- conferences designed to promote what makes college football fun - rivalry games
After the 70 BCS schools, there are 55 non-AQ teams in 4 conferences. They play in a conference championship game. Maybe the right 13-0 non-AQ team w/ enough BCS wins during their undefeated season could earn the at-large bid.
| Western Athletic | Conference USA | |||||
| Mountain | West | East | West | |||
| UTEP | Nevada | Marshall | Tulane | |||
| New Mexico | UNLV | East Carolina | Louisiana Tech | |||
| Colorado State | San Jose State | Birmingham | Houston | |||
| Wyoming | Fresno State | Southern Miss | Rice | |||
| Utah State | San Diego State | Central Florida | Southern Methodist | |||
| Idaho | Hawaii | South Florida | Tulsa | |||
- mid-tier conferences. WAC on the left coast
- CUSA on the right.
| Mid-American | Sunbelt | |||||
| East | West | East | West | |||
| UMass | Toledo | Florida Atlantic | Arkansas State | |||
| Temple | Bowling Green | Florida International | Louisiana Monroe | |||
| Buffalo | Eastern Michigan | South Alabama | Louisiana Lafayette | |||
| Ohio | Central Michigan | Troy | Texas State | |||
| Miami | Western Michigan | Georgia State | North Texas | |||
| Akron | Ball State | Middle Tennessee | UTSA | |||
| Kent State | Northern Illinois | Western Kentucky | New Mexico State | |||
bottom rung. 1 in the North & 1 in the South. 14-teams each
8 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
uhhh, the Mid Majors still have the same problem they do now
Maybe the right 13-0 non-AQ team w/ enough BCS wins during their undefeated season could earn the at-large bid.
If Houston had gone undefeated they’d be griping about playing for a title in both scenarios.
Also, 8 team play off? You really only need a plus 1. Nobody really thinks that there are more than 4 teams that should be playing for a title at the end of the season.
I like Turtles!
Follow @HarryHareBear
by RedTurtle on Dec 17, 2025 3:30 PM EST reply actions
Easily solvable.
Keep everything as Idle has it (maybe not Memphis, lol)
Include all the second tier teams (No bottom rung) as 4 conferences. Have the conference champs play for a Gold Cup, silver football, crystal plate, ect…Championship. You could even have at large incorporated. Not hard at all. Just add byes for your 2 top rank teams.
Now, if you feel your team is an actual title contender, not just a coulda, shoulda woulda, then you can forfeit your title rights, and your chance of winning the second tier championship, for a legit shot. Teams will then have to sacrifice to get a shot.
Then they would have to play an at large team at their stadium just to qualify. Teams know how good they are, and they aren’t going to throw all that away for a pipe dream. A Division Title, Conference Title, Region Title & National (Crystal Plate) Title. Schools love hardware, and that’s a lot of hardware.
An interesting development might occur. Some of the teams from the “Big Boys” might drop down or trade places with some of the second tier conferences.
If you ever wanted to see Boise St play...may be a good chance. Love em or Hate em, they are always interesting; and now, no matter where you live, "They're Coming To Your City"
by astrosmurf on Jan 8, 2026 10:48 PM EST up reply actions
No
You have the old SWC/B12 South wrong. Houston and SMU were in the SWC.
Memphis TOO far to fit and no historic rivalry.
LSU not in the SEC? Them SEC boys would come hurt you man.
by the electricAlan on Dec 18, 2025 2:41 PM EST reply actions
Yeah it's cool to just not have a founding member of the SEC (LSU) in it...
Big East Coast Bias
One-Handed Grab
Twitter
by Patrick_the_Ruminator on Dec 18, 2025 2:51 PM EST up reply actions
Or you could go back to 1991 & never mess with things & ask the 7 BCS conferences to please pay round robin 9-game schedules.
Big 10 - same
Pac 10 - same
SEC 10 - same, no Arkansas & Sakerlina expansion
ACC 10 - Sakerlina never left & FSU still joins
Big 8 + 2 = 10 - add in Utah & BYU
BEast 10 = classic 7 of BC, Cuse, Rutgers, Pitt, West Va, Va Tech, Miami… kick out Temple (of course)… add in young UConn & USF programs… score Penn St over B1G
SWC 10 = now this conf had problems w/ 8 Tx teams. kick out SMU, Rice, Houston. add in Memphis, Louisville, Cincinnati & Boise State (or leave Houston if you like geography over tv markets)
by Idle on Dec 20, 2025 9:31 PM EST reply actions
Nice work Idle
I did the same kind of work 3 years ago, and I know what you went through to try to make everybody happy. I finally gave up and created more of a regional plan, so the only bickering would be done regionally, which most teams and fan bases could handle. Believe me, their will be bickering no matter what, so forget conferences & start drawing lines. As long as you have one conference that thinks their superior or special, they will always screw up your logic.
Lets get the control away from the money boys, and help the NCAA grow some balls again. Do Texas a favor and cut em in half, they might like that?
If you ever wanted to see Boise St play...may be a good chance. Love em or Hate em, they are always interesting; and now, no matter where you live, "They're Coming To Your City"
by astrosmurf on Jan 9, 2026 1:35 AM EST up reply actions

by Idle on 






